Right Care, Right Person Explained: The Threshold, the Phases, and What It Means for the NHS
Right Care, Right Person changes who turns up. Under the model, police no longer attend mental health, welfare and vulnerability calls by default. They attend where there is a crime to investigate, or where there is a real and immediate risk to life or of serious harm. Everything else is expected to be met by health or social care.
The principle is difficult to argue with. A police officer is not a mental health clinician, and a uniformed response to someone in crisis often makes the situation worse rather than better. The argument has never really been about whether RCRP is right. It has been about whether the services expected to absorb the demand were ready to receive it.
This guide covers where the model came from, the exact threshold forces now apply, the phases it is rolled out in, which forces have adopted it, the criticism it has attracted, and what the evidence shows so far.
Key Statistic
Humberside Police recorded an average saving of 1,441 officer hours per month, and 46,114 hours in total between May 2020 and December 2022.
Those hours were released from mental health and welfare demand and returned to core policing. Source: Home Office and National Police Chiefs’ Council, July 2023.
What Does RCRP Mean?
RCRP stands for Right Care, Right Person, sometimes written as “right person, right care”. It is the national model under which police in England and Wales attend mental health, welfare and vulnerability calls only where there is a crime to investigate or a real and immediate risk to life or of serious harm. Other calls are passed to the health or social care service best placed to help.
Where Right Care, Right Person Came From

RCRP was developed by Humberside Police, not by central government. Work began in 2019, the force introduced the scheme in May 2020, and it was built out over roughly three years.
The starting observation was straightforward. A large share of Humberside’s demand involved people who needed a health response and were receiving a policing one instead, because policing was the service that answered the phone at three in the morning. Officers were sitting in emergency departments, conducting welfare checks on people known to mental health services, and searching for patients who had walked off wards.
The results Humberside reported were significant enough to attract national attention: an average of 1,441 officer hours released per month, and 46,114 hours in total between May 2020 and December 2022. In December 2022, the NPCC Chiefs’ Council agreed that all territorial forces in England and Wales would implement the model.
One figure attached to RCRP deserves care. The widely quoted claim that the model will save a million officer hours a year is an extrapolation, produced by applying the Humberside saving to other force populations. It is a projection of what might be achieved, not a record of what has been.
Talk to VICTOR
Find out how VICTOR gives trusts and forces the specialist response capability RCRP assumes. No obligation.
Call 0330 320 1159 Send an EmailThe National Partnership Agreement
The model became national policy through the National Partnership Agreement: Right Care, Right Person, published on 26 July 2023 and updated in April 2024.
Six organisations signed it: the Home Office, the Department of Health and Social Care, NHS England, the National Police Chiefs’ Council, the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners, and the College of Policing.
The agreement sets the principles and the threshold. It does not set a national deadline, which is why implementation dates differ so widely between forces. It is also an agreement for England. Wales sits outside it, for reasons covered below.
The Threshold: When Police Will and Will Not Attend

The threshold is the operational heart of RCRP, and it is worth quoting precisely. Police will attend where there is a need:
“to investigate a crime that has occurred or is occurring; or to protect people, when there is a real and immediate risk to the life of a person, or of a person being subject to or at risk of serious harm.”
Two phrases carry the weight. “Real and immediate” is a high bar, drawn from human rights case law. “Serious harm” excludes a great deal of distress that would previously have prompted an officer to attend.
The decision is made in the control room, at the point of call, by a call handler applying structured triage. That is a significant transfer of clinical judgement to a non-clinical setting, and it is where much of the criticism has landed.
The Four Phases of RCRP

NHS England’s implementation guidance, published in November 2024, sets out the phases in which forces withdraw from different categories of demand. Most forces work through them in order.
Mental health related welfare checks where there is no crime and no immediate risk to life.
People leaving an acute hospital before their treatment is complete.
Patients absent without leave from mental health inpatient settings.
Transporting people with mental health needs, which moves from police vehicles to health transport.
Reducing how long officers wait at a place of safety before handing over to health staff.
Phase 3 and Phase 4 are the ones that land hardest on ambulance trusts and mental health providers, because they transfer physical tasks rather than telephone triage. Conveying a distressed person, and taking custody of someone at a place of safety, both require the capability to manage a situation that may turn physical.
Which Police Forces Use Right Care, Right Person?
All territorial forces in England and Wales are committed to the model, but they went live at very different times. Publicly confirmed dates include:
- Humberside Police, phased from May 2020
- North Yorkshire Police, from 31 January 2023
- South Yorkshire Police, final phase October 2023
- Suffolk Constabulary, from 1 October 2023
- Metropolitan Police, live from 1 November 2023
- Norfolk Constabulary, from May 2024
- Greater Manchester Police, from 30 September 2024
The Met’s rollout is the most instructive. Sir Mark Rowley wrote to London health and social care partners on 24 May 2023 setting a deadline of 31 August. London’s mental health trusts pushed back on the timescale, and the date moved to 31 October, with the model live from 1 November 2023. The pattern of a force setting a date and health partners asking for more time repeated across the country.
Right Care, Right Person in Wales
The National Partnership Agreement is an England-only document. Welsh forces are not signatories to it.
All four Welsh forces, South Wales, North Wales, Dyfed-Powys and Gwent, are nonetheless adopting the principles, working with Welsh Government and partners through a national partnership group rather than a signed agreement. The practical effect on the ground is similar. The governance sitting behind it is not the same, which matters for any organisation operating across the border.
POLICY DATA
The Government’s own evaluation of RCRP measured police time saved. It did not measure patient health outcomes.
The Home Office and DHSC evaluation, published December 2024, found the main barrier to implementation was “capacity and resourcing limitations within health and social care”, and identified “potential gaps in services” as a key risk.
Source: Home Office and Department of Health and Social Care, December 2024
What RCRP Does Not Change: Section 136 and Section 135
A persistent misunderstanding is that RCRP has reduced police powers or duties under the Mental Health Act. It has not.
NHS England’s guidance is explicit that police will continue to fulfil their existing legal and statutory duties, including those under the Mental Health Act and their safeguarding duties for children and adults. The decision to use a power is still made by the officer at the scene.
Section 136, which allows an officer to remove someone to a place of safety, remains a police power and a police responsibility. Section 135 warrants, used to enter private premises, still require police attendance. What RCRP changes at Phase 4 is how quickly officers can hand over once someone is at a place of safety, not whether the detention happens.
The Criticism of Right Care, Right Person
Criticism of RCRP has come from mental health charities, parliamentarians, NHS leaders and coroners. Almost none of it disputes the principle. Nearly all of it concerns pace and readiness.
The Commons Health and Social Care Committee criticised what it described as a total lack of evaluation in terms of health outcomes, warned that forces were proceeding regardless of the readiness of health systems, and called for monitoring to ensure that people did not fall through the cracks.
Mind’s position captures the tension well. The charity accepts that police are not always the most appropriate people to support someone in crisis, while insisting that “keeping people safe is part of core police business and this can’t change: an emergency is an emergency.” It has also said it is extremely worried about the pace of the rollout.
The most serious criticism has come from a coroner. In a Prevention of Future Deaths report dated 15 October 2025, the Senior Coroner for Manchester North wrote to the College of Policing and the RCRP Strategic Partnership Board following the death of Katie Overd. The family had called the police first and then had to repeat the call to the ambulance service, causing delay. The coroner noted that a decision had been made not to undertake any proactive public communications about the implementation of RCRP.
That point is worth sitting with. The model reassigns responsibility between services, but the public was never told. A family in crisis still dials 999 and asks for the police, because that is what people have always done.
What the Evidence Shows So Far
The Home Office and DHSC evaluation published in December 2024, with case study work by the University of York and The King’s Fund, found early data showing a reduction in police time spent on RCRP related incidents. It identified capacity and resourcing limitations within health and social care as the main barrier to implementation, flagged potential gaps in services as a key risk, and recorded concerns that ambulance services may not be the most appropriate agency to respond to certain call types.
The limitation of that evaluation is as important as its findings. It examines the implementation process. It measures police time released. It does not measure what happened to the health of the people who no longer receive a police response. Two years into a national rollout, that evidence still does not exist.
The Capacity Question

Giving evidence to the Health and Social Care Committee, the then chief executive of Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust described NHS England scoping work suggesting that “something in the region of about £260 million might be needed to enable all of England to be in a position to respond appropriately” to RCRP demand.
That figure is often reported as the cost RCRP imposes on the NHS. It is more accurately described as an estimate of the investment required for the health service to be able to receive the demand safely. The distinction matters, because it frames the problem as a capability gap rather than a bill. We have covered the financial dimension separately in our analysis of the NHS capacity gap RCRP creates.
The capability being described is specific. It is not more call handlers or more beds. It is the ability to attend a situation involving a distressed and potentially volatile person, without police, and manage it safely. Very few NHS organisations have that capability today.
VICTOR: The Operational Partner That Makes RCRP Deliverable

RCRP asks forces to step back from calls that health services should own. It does not, on its own, give health services anything new to step forward with. A paramedic crew attending a call that police would have attended eighteen months ago is the same two clinicians, with the same training, facing a situation that has not become any less volatile.
VICTOR, the Violence Intervention and Crisis Threat Operational Response, exists to fill exactly that space. It is the only service in the UK providing a specialist, physically equipped, preemptive and responsive intervention capability designed for healthcare environments.
Operators train to police public order standards and prison tornado team protocols, carry PPE appropriate to clinical settings, and hold First Response Emergency Care Level 3. De-escalation is the objective on every deployment. The physical capability behind it is what makes de-escalation work, because an operator who knows what options they hold in reserve can afford to stay calm and keep talking.
The practical fit with RCRP is direct. For ambulance trusts absorbing Phase 1 and Phase 3 demand, VICTOR is a specialist asset crews can call, including preemptively when they can see a job is likely to escalate. For hospital trusts and mental health providers managing Phase 2 and Phase 4, it means clinical staff are not the people applying restraint, which protects the therapeutic relationship as well as everyone’s physical safety. For police forces, it is a partner that reduces the calls where officers are the only remaining option. For integrated care boards, a single contract can cover multiple trusts across a region.
Right Care, Right Person is the right principle. The right person, in a substantial number of these situations, is a specialist trained for healthcare environments and equipped to work in them. That is the resource the model assumed would exist.
Speak to VICTOR About Your Trust
VICTOR operates under a 6-9 month planning lead time. The earlier you make contact, the earlier you can have a preemptive response team in place.










